Will Void If Attorney Prepares A Will And Is Beneficiary

Robert Ray

Texas Rule

If an attorney prepares a will can the will name him as a beneficiary? The quick answer is no, it can’t.  Texas has a statute that says a devise or bequest of property in a will to an attorney or to an heir or employee of the attorney who prepares or supervises the preparation of the will is void. EC §254.003.

In a recent case, an attorney prepares a will. He had a woman working in his office that was an independent contractor.  She claimed that she was not an employee of the attorney.  She was a paralegal but she just did occasional work for the attorney.  She also did occasional work for other attorneys who shared office space with the attorney who drafted the will.  The will made her a beneficiary and also appointed her as the executor of the will.

The Will Contest

A sister of the testator contested the provisions of the will leaving part of the estate to the paralegal.  The court agreed with the sister finding that the paralegal met the definition of employee under the statute and ordered the paralegal to return all of the property that she had received to the heirs of the testator.  The court also ordered the paralegal to pay the attorney fees of the sister.

The paralegal appealed claiming that the statute did not apply to her since she was not an employee.  The appeals court disagreed and denied her appeal.  Jones v Krown.

Note:

A 2015 case out of Michigan indicates that Michigan law is different from Texas law. The Michigan case held that a will prepared by an attorney that left the attorney property was not necessarily void. The court held that under Michigan law, if the attorney could plead and prove that he did not unduly influence the testator, the will could be probated. The difference between Michigan and Texas is that a Texas statute declares the will void. There is no need to find that the attorney used undue influence. In Michigan, the rule is in their attorney’s Rules of Professional Conduct which are guidelines for attorneys’ conduct but don’t have the force of law like a statute. The attorney is presumed to have unduly influenced the testator but if the attorney can plead and prove that he did not exert undue influence, the will and the gift can be upheld. Florida has a similar rule, e.g. a gift to the attorney who prepares the will or his employees is not void but only voidable if undue influence can be shown. California too does not make the will void as it is in Texas but holds that it is presumed to be the product of fraud or undue influence.

UPDATES

There are new cases all the time that clarify or change the law on inheritance disputes. Keep up-to-date by subscribing to our blog.

'

Subscribe

Recent Posts

Statutory Probate Judges And Why You Want One

Statutory Probate Judges The largest counties in Texas have Statutory Probate Courts. Those courts handle all probate matters in these large counties. The judges of those courts are well-versed in probate law and procedure. If you have a contested probate matter, it...

Who Can Contest a Texas Probate?

Who Can Contest a Texas Probate Background In order to contest a Texas probate, you have to have standing. Standing means a person has a right to bring a lawsuit in Texas. To have standing in a Texas probate proceeding, you have to be an interested party. Facts In a...

Can You Have an Heirship Determination if There is a Will?

Heirship Proceedings in Texas The Texas Estates Code provides that the probate court "may conduct a proceeding to declare heirship when...a person dies intestate owning or entitled to property in this state and there has been no administration in this state of the...

The Author

Robert Ray

Robert Ray handles inheritance disputes of all kinds. He takes cases throughout Texas.
© Copyright 2024 | All Rights Reserved.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This