Good Faith Exception in Will Contest

Robert Ray

Good Faith Exception to No Contest Clauses in WillsGood Faith Exception

Texas and many other states will  enforce forfeiture clauses in wills if the contestant is not successful. The clauses are know as no contest provisions or in terrorem clauses . Texas has a Good Faith Exception in Will Contest involving no-contest clauses. There is an exception to enforcement if the person contesting the will brings the action in good faith. EC 254.005. In that case, the courts will not enforce no-contest forfeiture clauses.

Some states like Mississippi had not recognized the good faith exception to forfeiture but that has changed.  In 2015 the Mississippi Supreme Court in Parker v. Benoist recognized the good faith exception. The court stated that the logic for a good faith exception is simple: courts exist to determine the truth. A forfeiture clause that operates regardless of a party’s good faith in bringing suit to ascertain the validity of a will frustrates the fundamental purpose of a court, which is to determine whether a will is valid or not. Citing a Connecticut case the Mississippi Supreme Court noted “Courts cannot know whether a will, good on its face, was made in conformity to statutory requirements, whether the testator was of sound mind, and whether the will was the product of undue influence, unless these matters are presented in court. And those only who have an interest in the will will have the disposition to lay the facts before the court. If they are forced to remain silent, upon penalty of forfeiture of a legacy or devise given them by the will, the court will be prevented by the command of the testator from ascertaining the truth, and the devolution of property will be had in a manner against both statutory and common law. Courts exist to ascertain the truth and to apply it to a given situation, and a right of devolution which enables a testator to shut the door of truth and prevent the observance of the law is a mistaken public policy. If, on contest, the will should have been held invalid, the literal interpretation of the forfeiture provision has suppressed the truth and impeded the true course of justice. If the will should be held valid, no harm has been done through the contest, except the delay and the attendant expense.”

Successful Will Contest

Of course if the will contest is successful, then the entire will, including the no-contest clause, is void. The good faith issue only comes in to play when a contest is not successful and acts to prevent the forfeiture of any legacy that the contestant would receive under the contested will.

Was This Post Helpful

It may also be helpful to others so consider sharing it on Facebook, Twitter, Google+ or Linkedin by clicking the buttons.

Contact Us.

By Robert Ray a Board Certified attorney. The foregoing information is general in nature and does not apply to every fact situation. We handle litigation involving inheritance disputes. We don’t prepare wills. We don’t file wills for probate or distribute estates except when we are contesting a will or protecting a will from a contest. We handle a select few cases on contingency. Don’t use a comment to ask a personal question about an inheritance issue because your name and comment will be public. To ask a litigation question and to protect your privacy, click the red button to the right.

UPDATES

There are new cases all the time that clarify or change the law on inheritance disputes. Keep up-to-date by subscribing to our blog.

'

Subscribe

Recent Posts

How do I claim my inheritance Texas

How do I claim my inheritance Texas

Claiming an inheritance in Texas An inheritance can never compensate for the death of a family member. But inheritance is not about greed; it is about custody and control of your property. Claiming an inheritance in Texas is usually straightforward if you are a named...

Don’t Use Wills Found on the Internet

Don’t Use Wills Found on the Internet

The IssueIn a case out of the Fort Worth Court of Appeals, the issue was what power did the trustee have to distribute or not distribute assets of the trust.The beneficiaries of the trust sued the trustee to require him to distribute the assets to them. The trustee, a...

WHAT CONSTITUTES A SIGNATURE ON A WILL

WHAT CONSTITUTES A SIGNATURE ON A WILL

What constitutes a signature A holographic will is one that is wholly in the handwriting of the testator and signed by him. What constitutes a signature is often contested. Texas recognizes holographic wills but other states do not. The difference between a...

Precatory words in a Texas will

Precatory words in a Texas will What are precatory words? Precatory words are words that are a request or a desire. These are seen mostly in self-made wills. The problems with these words are:  do the words pass title? Examples of precatory words Occasionally, when...

The slayer rule doesn’t always apply

Texas Slayer Rule Recent UK case on the Slayer Rule The Texas Slayer Rule is different from other state's and countries' rule but has procedures to accomplish the same end result. See this discussion. The Texas Slayer Rule is a rule that court's use to prevent a...

Podcast – Contesting a will with a no contest clause

Podcast added! The topic is "Contesting a will with a no contest clause" Many people are concerned about contesting a will in Texas because they know that the will has a no contest clause. (Almost all wills have a no contest clause in them). In this podcast, we will...

The Author

Robert Ray

Robert Ray handles inheritance disputes of all kinds. He takes cases throughout Texas.
© Copyright 2022 | All Rights Reserved.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This